14th December 2014 is the final day for Chiang Mai Design Week under the auspices of the TCDC ( Thailand Creative Design Center, part of the Prime Minister’s office), events and displays having commenced on the 6th .
This may come a surprise to many Thai folk who cannot read English, as the many signs around town advertising the event are all in English. As for the residents of this multi-cultural city those who can, they might have expected the week to feature visiting presenters from ASEAN and wider afield.
On 12th an event advertised as “Creative Dialogue” was held between 4 and 7 pm. I went knowing only that I wanted to hear one of the nine speakers, who lucky for me turned out to be the first. No program was on hand so I did not know what to expect in the three hour session, except dialogue. All the talks were given in Thai and simultaneous translation was given by a headset, but apart from myself I could see no other foreign faces in the packed to over flowing auditorium.After 70 minutes with 4 very interesting presentations by imaginative and inspiring folk all of whom were from Thailand and working here I decided to depart.
Why did I leave early? Because I felt somewhat like the folk in the above protest photo taken from the Bangkok Post. No the police were not breathing down my neck but no time had been given for dialogue, neither among the speakers, nor with the audience.
Maybe in my case this was a good thing as when the first speaker told us how the use of earth and vegetation to protect riverbanks is far more effective and far less costly than the present unabated building of concrete walls along the Ping River, I might have been moved to chip in with a comment critical of the government. Similarly I was saved the task of correcting one speaker who mistakenly said that roadside vegetation reduces noise problems or the comment that Yang Na is a native tree in Chiang Mai, while all the evidence suggests otherwise.
I feel sad for the other attendees though, who must have had questions they could not raise in a timely manner, and those who went away with misinformation or the impression that dialogue means passively listening.
I suggest TCDC consider these criticisms and develop a more consultative and participatory approach to their work.
They have built an impressive resource center with a spacious large library with a wonderful collection of titles, almost all in English. To use the library one must pay an annual subscription which Chiang Mai’s many design professionals will find a good investment.
The library and meeting room is situated in the grounds of the Lanna Ladies Club which is at the corner of the road from the moat to the White Chedi, just east of the President Hotel.
These pictures show:
1. the Ladies Club lawn looking south, lovely to play lawn bowls if they can stand the heat of the sun.
2. The TCDC building with the library on the top floor.
3. The priority given to electric wires over an old tree, cut to suit. Rather than placing the wires underground, beginning from the road, they have been extended some 20 metres ontot the TCDC land and then placed underground to travel a short distance beneath the car park where trees for shade are not planted.
4. Trees – all showy Lagerstroemias have been planted along the adjacent foot path where wires are not an issue. Had the designer read Dr Preecha Ongprasert’s doctoral thesis on the street trees of Chiang Mai, this is the last genus they would have planted. Many straight growing local species including evergreen trees would be preferable.
Judging from the excellent turnout at Friday’s event Chiang Mai Design Week must be regarded as a success in providing opportunities for networking among professionals.
Next year the organisers might like to consider how they can make a contribution beneficial to the great majority of Chiang Mai folk including the many who will likely gain no benefit from the kind of high end design displayed this year.
Post Script:
Adjacent to TCDC is the Provincial Electoral Office, now turned into a display venue, and behind that a few ancient trees and pond. Rubbish is all around, but a clean up by a group of volunteers like iServe could turn this into a delightful mini park away from the grime and hustle and bustle and stench of the Mueng Mai market.
From Our Facebook page comments :
Rick Wong likes this.
Ricky Ward What thinkest Martin Venzky-Stalling ?
20 hrs · Like · 1
Martin Venzky-Stalling I think it is a very personal perspective, not quite balanced. TCDC put together a huge event with many activities, it can be criticized from many angles, particularly that the organization was too coordinated and controlled from Bangkok. But why not first focus on all the good things rather than jump just into criticism. Overall it was great and good for Chiang Mai. Learn and move on, next year it will be better. I think they had the right attentions and they also organized a lot of activities where people could have continued conversations about things they saw and heard. The dialogue part and the networking events could have been organized a bit differently and with more local involvement, but overall it was and is a great event.
20 hrs · Like · 2
Ricky Ward Yes I agree Martin, “a very personal perspective, not quite balanced”, not surprising as I did not have time to go to many events, and as I said I thought it a success for the networkers for sure. Let’s encourage them to do it again with wider local involvement as you say. I was very happy that I found out about and met Aj Julaporn thanks to TCDC. My criticism extends beyond the event, their failure to follow examples elsewhere when it comes to electric wires shows a lost opportunity and a feeling they do not represent excellence.
18 hrs · Like
Michael Heath Ricky – I second the idea of adding more panels, with local experts, to discuss melding architecture with the environment. Countries such as Singapore could offer lessons on how they’ve dealt with the ‘wire issue’ for example. Bangkok certainly needs it.
Michael Heath’s photo.
14 hrs · Unlike · 1
Martin Venzky-Stalling We had representatives from Bandung, Cebu and Penang in one of the panels. They shared great ideas on city development. But there was not so much discussion at the end and many people who should have been there weren’t there. Maybe a bit less next year but more depth.
13 hrs · Like
Bamboo Roo More depth and enlightenment from the fields of urban design, architecture, landscape architecture and city design would be a great. Chiang Mai could really benefit from a “creative city plan” and of course more bamboo!!
12 hrs · Like
Ricky Ward Perhaps we would be better to organize something here Martin, e.g. TedX ? I went to TCDC before the event and asked about landscape issues and was told nothing about the ASEAN folk and their panel. Nor could I fathom what was happening looking at the printed program. Are the talks/discussions going to be on Youtube? They could be used as discussion starters and presenters could even Skype in to a meeting session.